I started advertising The Shanghai Circle in The Online Book Club, and reviews began arriving in mid-October 2023 and currently total 158, of which 98% are 5 or 4 stars
Here is the Original review by the Online Book Club
These are reviews by members
October 2023
14th Oct – 4* 16th Oct -1st – 4* 16th Oct – 2nd – 4* 17th Oct – 1st – 5*
17th Oct – 2nd – 4* 17th Oct – 3rd – 4* 18th Oct – 1st – 5* 18th Oct – 2nd –5*
19th Oct – 4* 20th Oct – 1st- 5* 20th Oct – 2nd – 3* 21st Oct 1st – 5*
21st Oct 2nd – 4* 22nd Oct – 5* 23rd October – 5* 24th Oct – 1st —4*
24th Oct – 2nd – 4* 24th Oct – 3rd – 4* 24th Oct – 4th – 5* 25th Oct – 4*
27th Oct – 4* 28th Oct – 4* 29th Oct – 3*
November 2023
1st Nov – 5* 4th Nov – 1st – 4* 4th Nov – 2nd – 5* 7th Nov – 5*
9th Nov -1st – 4* 9th Nov – 2nd – 4* 12th Nov – 4* 18th Nov – 4*
23rd Nov – 4* 26th Nov 1st – 5* 26th Nov – 2nd – 4*
December 2023
3rd Dec – 4* 4th Dec 1st – 5* 4th Dec – 2nd – 4* 6th Dec – 4*
8th Dec – 4* 9th Dec– 1st – 4* 9th Dec – 2nd – 4* 9th Dec – 3rd – 4*
9th Dec – 4th –4* 10th Dec – 5* 11th Dec – 5* 13th Dec – 4*
17th Dec – 5* 18th Dec 1st –5* 18th Dec- 2nd – 4* 19th Dec – 1st – 5*
19th Dec – 2nd – 4* 19th Dec – 3rd – 4* 22nd Dec – 4* 27th Dec – 5*
28th Dec – 1st – 4* 28th Dec – 2nd – 4* 28th Dec – 3rd – 5* 29th Dec- 1 – 5*
29th Dec – 2- 4* 30th Dec – 4* 31st Dec – 1st – 5* 31st Dec – 2nd – 4*
31st Dec – 3rd – 4* 31st Dec – 4 – 4*
January 2024
1st Jan – 4* 2nd Jan – 1st – 5* 2nd Jan – 2nd – 5* 3rd Jan – 1st – 5*
3rd Jan – 2nd – 4* 3rd Jan – 3rd – 5* 3rd Jan – 4th – 5* 12th Jan – 4*
13th Jan – 1st – 5* 13th Jan – 2nd – 4* 14th Jan – 4* 15th Jan – 4*
16th Jan – 4* 17th Jan – 5* 21st Jan – 4* 29th Jan – 5*
February 2024
4th Feb – 5* 11th Feb – 4* 14th Feb – 4* 15th Feb – 5*
17th Feb – 5* 22nd Feb – 4* 23rd Feb – 5* 24th Feb – 1st – 5*
24th Feb – 2nd – 5* 25th Feb – 1st – 4* 25th Feb -2nd – 4*
March 2024
3rd March – 5* 4th March – 5* 5th March – 5* 7th March – 4*
8th March – 4* 9th March – 4* 11th March – 4* 12th March – 1st – 4*
12th March – 2nd – 5* 13th March – 1st- 5* 13th March – 2nd – 5* 15th March – 5*
16th March – 5* 18th March – 1 – 5* 18th March – 2 – 5* 19th March – 1st – 5*
19th March – 2nd – 4* 19th March – 3rd – 4* 20th March – 5* 21st March – 5*
22nd March – 4* 25th March – 1 – 5* 25th March – 2 – 4* 26th March – 5*
29th March – 5* 30th March – 4*
April 2024
1st April – 5* 2nd April – 1 – 5* 2nd April – 2 – 5* 3rd April – 1- 4*
3rd April – 2 – 4* 4th April – 5* 8th April – 1 – 5* 8th April – 2 – 5*
9th April – 5* 11th April – 4* 13th April – 5* 17th April – 1 – 4*
17th April – 2 – 4* 18th April – 4* 21st April – 1 – 5* 21st April – 2 – 5*
21st April – 3 – 4* 21st April – 4 – 4* 22nd April – 4* 23rd April – 1 – 5*
23rd April – 2 – 4* 23rd April – 3 – 4* 23rd April – 4 – 4* 24th April – 5*
25th April – 4* 26th April – 1- 4* 26th April – 2 – 5* 27th April – 5*
28th April – 1 – 5* 28th April – 2 – 4* 30th April – 1 – 5*
May 2024
1st May – 5* 3rd May – 5* 4th May – 5* 8th May – 4*
10th May – 1 – 5* 10th May – 2 – 5* 11th May – 5* 13th May – 5*
14th May – 4* 18th May – 5* 20th May – 5* 22nd May – 5*
25th May – 5* 28th May – 4* 31st May – 5*
June 2024
1st June – 4* 4th June – 4* 5th June – 3*